Is Marketplace Health Insurance Really ‘Affordable’? What Most Freelancers & Business Owners Don’t Know

If you’ve ever searched for health insurance online, you’ve probably seen the word “affordable” tossed around like confetti. But for freelancers, self-employed families, and small business owners, the truth behind those prices often tells a very different story.

So before you lock into another year of confusing deductibles, skyrocketing premiums, and limited networks — here’s what you really need to know about ACA Marketplace plans vs. private alternatives.

1. The Monthly Premium Might Be the Least Important Number

Many buyers look at the lowest premium and assume they’re getting the best deal. But premium is just one part of the equation. Here’s what you’re often not seeing upfront:

• Deductibles: Many Bronze and Silver ACA plans come with deductibles over $8,000 per person.
• Out-of-Pocket Max: You could still be on the hook for $17,000+ per family even after insurance kicks in.
• Restricted Networks: Some ACA plans limit you to a local HMO, which may not include your preferred doctors.

2. Freelancers Often Don’t Qualify for the Subsidies They Were Promised

ACA tax credits are income-based. But self-employed income isn’t always consistent — and many business owners find out at tax time that they “earned too much” and must pay back those credits.

If your income:

• fluctuates month to month,
• includes 1099/contract work,
• or is hard to estimate accurately...

Then it’s critical to explore non-marketplace options that aren’t based on your AGI or IRS filings.

3. Families Are Paying More for Less Coverage

Let’s look at a real-world example.

Lexi, a freelance designer from Texas with two kids, was paying $1,243/month for a Silver ACA plan.
After switching to a private PPO through TrueClarity Plans, her monthly cost dropped to $726/month — with $0 deductible and virtual care included.

These numbers aren’t flukes — they’re increasingly common for families who don’t qualify for full subsidies and want year-round PPO access.

4. What Private Plans Do Differently

Private health coverage isn't a one-size-fits-all solution, but the best ones offer:

• Nationwide PPO networks
• Options with $0 deductible
• Year-round enrollment (no deadlines!)
• Custom quoting based on age, health, and location — not IRS subsidies

Private plans are especially helpful if you’re:

• Self-employed
• Healthy but uninsured
• Paying for your own or your family’s coverage
• Outside subsidy range (or hate dealing with government forms)

Who Should Stick with ACA Marketplace Plans?

To be clear, ACA is a lifesaver for many — and we help clients access those plans when they qualify.

Stick with Marketplace if:

• You earn below 250% of the Federal Poverty Level
• You or a family member has chronic conditions or major surgeries upcoming
• You qualify for $0 premium Medicaid plans in your state

The key is knowing your options, not guessing.

Final Word: Don’t Just “Pick a Plan” — Build the Right Strategy

Choosing the wrong plan can cost you thousands every year — not just in premiums, but in taxes, medical bills, and stress.

Our team at TrueClarity Plans exists to remove the guesswork. We compare ACA, private, and short-term options side by side, and match you to the coverage that’s best for your actual needs.

‍